International Journal of Housing and Human Settlement Planning
A Realist Philosophical Approach for Housing Research: Critical Realism
Abstract
AbstractThe development of housing studies as an academic discipline from its roots in the 1970s has seen research undertaken into a range of phenomena associated with housing, home and society. Different philosophical approaches have been adopted by housing researchers in their studies to help them to carry out their explorations, examinations and investigations. This article presents an analysis of one philosophical approach which can help the housing researcher in their quest for knowledge. It looks at the philosophy of Critical Realism (CR), the relationship that it has with housing studies and how it can be used as an approach within housing research. Three core aspects are looked at through three parts within the article. The first part provides an introduction to CR, describing key aspects and highlighting fundament parts of the philosophical approach. The second part of the article considers the role of philosophy in relation to research and the overall approaches that underlie philosophical approaches. The third part of the article focuses on realism in housing research and compares social constructionist and CR approaches within this philosophical tradition in relation to their appropriateness for research within the field of housing studies. At the end of the article the main strands are brought together in a concluding section.References (99)
- BHASKAR R, (1998), The logic of discovery. IN M ARCHER, R BHASKAR, A COLLIER, T LAWSON AND A NORRIE, Critical Realism: Essential Readings, London: Routledge, 16-47
- LAWSON J M, (2002), Thin Rationality, Weak Constructionism and Critical Realism. The way forward in housing theory? Housing Theory and Society, 19 (3/4), 142-144
- LAWSON J M, (2001), Comparing the Causal Mechanisms underlying Housing Networks over Time and Space, Netherland Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, Amsterdam
- BHASKAR R, (1975), Realist Theory of Science, London: Verso
- BHASKAR R, (1989), Reclaiming Reality, A Critical Introduction in Contemporary Philosophy, London: Verso
- BHASKAR R, (1991), Philosophy and the idea of freedom, Oxford: Blackwell
- BHASKAR R, (1998a), Critical Realism, New York: Routledge
- BHASKAR R, (1998b), The Possibility of Naturalism: A Philosophical Critique of the Contemporary Human Sciences, New York: Routledge
- COLLIER A, (1994), Critical Realism: An introduction to Roy Bhaskar’s Philosophy, London: Verso
- ARCHER M S, (1995), Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- ARCHER M S, (1996), Culture and Agency: The Place of Culture in Social Theory, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- ARCHER M S, (2000), Being Human: The Problem of Agency, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- ARCHER M S, (2003), Structure, Agency and the Internal Conversation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- ARCHER M S, (2007), Making our Way through the World: Human Reflexivity and Social Mobility, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- SAYER A, (1984), Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach, London: Routledge
- SAYER A, (1992), Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach (Second Ed), London: Routledge
- SAYER A, (2000), Realism and Social Science, London: SAGE Publications
- SAYER A, (2010), Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach, (Revised Second Ed), London: Routledge
- DYSON S AND BROWN B, (2005), Social Theory and Applied Health Research, Buckingham: Open University Press
- RYAN S AND S PORTER, (1996), ‘Breaking the boundaries between Nursing and Sociology: A Critical Realist Ethnography of the Theory-Practice Gap’, Journal of Advanced Nursing, 24: 413-420
- WAINWRIGHT S P, (1997), ‘A new paradigm for Nursing: the potential of Realism’, Journal of Advanced Nursing, 26: 1262-1271
- FLEETWOOD S AND ACKROYD S, (2004), Critical Realist Applications in Organisation and Management Studies, London: Routledge
- HOUSTON S, (2010), ‘Prising Open the Black Box: Critical Realism, Action Research and Social Work’, Qualitative Social Work, 9(1): 73-91
- FITZPATRICK S, (2005), Explaining Homelessness: A Critical Realist Perspective, Housing, Theory and Society, Vol 22, no 1 1-17
- SCHOSTAK J, (2002), Critiquing Critical Realism: A Working Paper, ECER Conference, Portugal
- PROUT A, (2005), The Future of Childhood: Towards the Interdisciplinary Study of Children, London: Routledge Falmer Press
- O’MAHONEY J AND VINCENT S, (2014), Critical Realism as an Empirical Project. IN P EDWARDS, J O’MAHONEY AND S VINCENT (Eds), Studying Organisations using Critical Realism – A Practical Guide, Oxford: Oxford University Press
- BHASKAR R, (1978), A Realist Theory of Science, Hassocks: Harvester Press
- EASTON G, (2009), Critical Realism in Case Studies, Industrial Marketing Management, 39, pp 118-128
- BUNGE M, (2004), ‘How does it work? The search for Explanatory Mechanisms, Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 34, 2 pp 182-210
- BRYGSTAD B AND MUNKVOLD B E, (2011), In Search of Mechanisms. Conducting a Critical Realist Data Analysis, Thirty Second International conference on Information Systems, Shanghai
- MINGERS J AND WILCOCKS L P (Eds), (2004), Domains of the Real, the Actual and the Empirical, Social Theory and Philosophy for Information Systems, London: John Wiley
- SMITH S P AND JOHNSTON R B, (2014), How Critical Realism Clarifies Validity Issues in Information Systems Theory-Testing Research, Scandinavian journal of Information Systems, 26(1), 5-28
- SALMON W C, (1984) Scientific Explanation and the Causal Structure of the World, Princeton: Princeton University Press
- HULSWIT M, (2002), From Cause to Causation: A Peircean Perspective, Dordrecht: Kluwer Publishers
- RADUESCU C AND VESSEY I, (2008), Causality in Critical Realism Research: An Analysis of three Explanatory Models, International Association for Critical Realism Annual Conference, London 11-13 July 2008
- PAWSON R, (2008) ‘Causality for Beginners’, ESRC/NCRM Research Methods Festival.
- HARRE R, (1970), The Principles of Scientific Thinking, London: Macmillan
- HARRE R AND MADDEN E H, (1975), Causal Powers, Oxford: Blackwell
- BHASKAR R, (1975), Realist Theory of Science, London: Verso
- SOMERVILLE P, (2012), Critical Realism, International Encyclopaedia of Housing & Home, Elsevier, pp 291-295
- BRAMLEY G AND FITZPATRICK S, (2017), Homelessness in the UK: Who is most at Risk? Housing Studies, 1-21
- ELDER-VASS D, (2005), Emergence and the Realist Account of Cause, Journal of Critical Realism, 4:2, pp 315-38.
- MIHATA K, (1997), The persistence of "emergence"'. In RAYMOND A EVE, SARA HORSFALL AND MARY E LEE, Chaos, Complexity, and Sociology Thousand Oaks, Calif: Sage
- BUCKLEY W, (1998), Society: A Complex Adaptive System, Australia: Gordon and Breach
- EMMECHE C, KOPPE S AND STJERNFELT, (1997), Explaining emergence: towards an ontology of levels, Journal for General Philosophy of Science, vol. 28:1
- ARCHER M, (1982), 'Morphogenesis versus Structuration', British Journal of Sociology, 33, 455-83
- ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL RESEARCH COUNCIL (ESRC), (2007), Research Ethics Framework, Swindon: ESRC
- MERTENS D, (2005), Research and Evaluation in Education and Psychology: Integrating diversity with Quantitative, Qualitative, and Mixed Methods (Second Ed), Boston: SAGE Publications
- NEW C, (2007), Realising the Potential: The ESRC Seminar Series on Social Realism and Empirical Research, Journal of Critical Realism, 4(1), 4347.
- KNIGHT A AND TURNBULL N, (2008), Epistemology. IN A KNIGHT AND L RUDDOCK (Eds), Advanced Research Methods in the Built Environment, Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell
- CROTTY M, (2003), The Foundations of Social Research (Secons Ed), London; SAGE Publications
- GRIX J, (2004), The Foundations of Research, Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan
- BRYMAN A, (2004), Social research methods (Second Ed), New York: Oxford University Press
- HOLDEN M T AND LYNCH P, (2004), Choosing the Appropriate Methodology: Understanding Research Philosophy, The Marketing Review, 4, (4), 347-409
- KULATUNGA K, AMARATUNGA D AND HAIGH R, (2008), Researching ‘Construction, Client and Innovation’: Pilot study and analysis, Salford: University of Salford
- BURRELL G AND MORGAN G, (1979), Sociological Paradigms and Organisational
- Analysis, Hampshire: Ashgate.
- EVELY A C, FAZEY I, PINARD M AND LAMBIN X, (2008), The influence of philosophical perspectives in integrative research: A conservation case study in the Cairngorms National Park, Ecology and Society, 13(2): 52
- SAUNDERS M, LEWIS P AND THORNHILL A, (2003), Research Methods for Business Students (Third Ed), London: Pearson Education
- KEMENY J, KERSLOOT J AND THALMANN P, (2005), Non-Profit Housing influencing, leading and dominating the Unitary Rental Market: Three Case Studies, Housing Studies, 20 (6): 855-872
- BALL M AND HARLOE M, (1992), Rhetorical barriers to understanding housing provision: What the 'provision thesis' is and is not, Housing Studies, 7(1), 3-15.
- FRANKLIN B AND CLAPHAM D, (1997), ‘The Social Construction of Housing Management’, Housing Studies, 12(1), 7-26
- DIDACTIC ENCYCLOPEDIA, (2015), What is the Meaning of Realism.
- PUTNAM H, (1999), The threefold cord: Mind, Body and World, New York: Columbia University Press
- MULAIK S, (2010), Linear Causal Modelling with Structural Equalities, Journal of Classification, 27 (3), pp 404-407
- CHAKRAVARRTY A, (2004), Structuralism as a form of Scientific Realism, International Studies in the Philosophy of Science, 18:151–171
- YEUNG H W, (1997), Critical Realism and Realist Research in Human Geography: A Method or a Philosophy in Search of a Method? Progress in Human Geography 21:51–74
- BASSET K AND SHORT J, (1980), Housing and Residential Structure, London: Routledge and Keagan Paul
- PARK R E, BURGESS E W AND MCKENZIE R D, (1925), The City, Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press
- ALONSO W, (1964), Location and Land Use, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press
- PAHL R E, (1975), Whose City? (Second Ed), Harmondsworth: Penguin
- HARVEY D, (1973), Social Justice and the City, Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press
- CASTELLS M, (1977), The Urban Question, London: Arnold
- ENGELS F, (1872), The Housing Question, Moscow: Progress Publishers
- LAWSON J M, (2009), A review of structurally inspired approaches in housing studies – concepts, contributions and future perspectives, Paper presented to RC 43 INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE Housing Assets, Housing People, Glasgow September 1 – 4, 2009
- BALL M, (1983) Housing Policy and Economic Power: The Political Economy of Owner Occupation, London: Methuen
- BALL M, (1998) Institutions in British Property Research: A Review, Urban Studies, 35: 1501-1517
- BALL M, (1988), Housing provision and comparative housing research. In Housing and social change in Europe and the USA. IN M BALL. M HARLOE AND M MARTENS (Eds), New York: Routledge
- AMBROSE P, (1991), The Housing Provision Chain as a Comparative Analytical Framework, Scandinavian Housing and Planning Research, 8 (2): 91-104
- AMBROSE P, (1994), Urban Process and Power, London: Routledge
- BALL M, (1986), Housing Analysis: Time for a Theoretical Refocus? Housing Studies, 1 (3): 147-165
- GORE T AND NICHOLSON D, (1991), Models of the Land Development Process: A Critical Review, Environment and Planning, Vo1.23 pp 705-730
- Giddens A, (1984), The Constitution of society: Outline of the theory of structuration, Thousand Oaks, CA: University of California Press
- HARLOE M, (1995), The Peoples Home: Social Rented Housing in Europe and America, Oxford: Blackwell
- KEMENY J, (1995), From Public Housing to Social Market: Rental Policy in Comparative Perspective, London: Routledge
- JACOBS K, KEMENY J AND MANZI T, (2017), Introduction. IN K JACOBS, J KEMENY AND T MANZI (Eds), Social Constructionism in Housing Research, Routledge
- SOMERVILLE P AND BENGTSSON B, (2002), Constructionism, Realism and Social Theory, Housing, Theory and Society, 19: 3-4, 121-136
- CLAPHAM D, (2018), Remaking Housing Policy: An international Study, London: Routledge
- GIBB K AND MARSH A, (2019), Housing and Systems Thinking (working paper), Glasgow: Cache
- FOPP R J, (2008), 'Social Constructionism and Housing Studies: A Critical Reflection', Urban Policy and Research, vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 159-175
- JACOBS K AND MANZI T, (2013), Modernisation, Marketisation and Housing Reform: The use of evidence based policy as a Rationality Discourse, People, Place & Policy Online, 7/1, pp. 1-13.
- KING P, (2004), ‘Relativism, Subjectivity and the Self: A Critique of Social Constructionism.’ IN K JACOBS, J KEMENY AND T MANZI, Social constructionism in Housing Research Hampshire, England: Ashgate, 32-48
- WOOLGAR S AND PAWLUCH D, (1985), ‘Ontological Gerrymandering’, Social Problems, 32: 214-227
- COLLIN F, (1997), Social Reality, London: Routledge
- CRUIKSHANK J, (2011), The positive and the negative - Assessing critical realism and social constructionism as post-positivist approaches to empirical research in the social sciences. Working Paper 42, Oxford: Oxford University
- TAYLOR S P, (2018), Critical Realism vs Social Constructionism & Social Constructivism: Application to a Social Housing Research Study, International Journal of Science: Basic and Applied, Vol 37, Issue 2, pp 216-222
- JACOBS K AND MANZI T, (2000), ‘Evaluating the Social Constructivist Paradigm in Housing Research’, Housing, Theory and Society, 17: 35-42
- SOMERVILLE P, (1994), On Explanations of Policy, Scandinavian Housing and Planning Research, 11 (4): 211–230